Front of pack of Bulla Murray Street Ice Creamery Banoffee Ice Cream sitting on a kitchen bench

Review Of Murray Street Ice Creamery Banoffee Ice Cream

Murray St Ice Creamery Banoffee 1L is a relatively new ice cream in Australian supermarket freezers. It hit the shelves at the same time as the Choc Mint Sundae variant. This review looks at whether it’s worth your money.

Murray St Choc Mint & Banoffee Ice Cream Tubs side by side on a countertop.
Two tubs ready for tasting.

Quick rundown

Bulla produces Murray Street Ice Creamery Banoffee Ice Cream as part of a range of one-litre tubs. The brand is positioned as a premium product competing head-on with Connoisseur. It is more affordable than super-premium brands like Haagen-Dazs and Ben & Jerry’s.

Bulla describes these tubs as the “creamiest premiumest” ice cream they make.

Top down image of Murray St Banoffee ice cream with the lid off, unscooped.
The opened tub of Banoffee ice cream.

Is it worth the money?

Bulla Murray St Banoffee starts with banana flavoured ice cream and adds ribbons of toffee caramel sauce. It’s a delicious ice cream that most should enjoy if they like the taste of banana.

The banana ice cream base is what you would expect from Murray St Ice Creamery products. It’s incredibly creamy and indulgent, thanks to fresh cream, milk, and free-range egg yolk.

Driving my spoon into the frozen dessert revealed hidden pockets of caramel sauce. Unlike some mix-ins that turn hard and icy once frozen, this one quickly turned mouth-wateringly oozy once removed from the freezer.

A scoop of Banoffee Ice Cream by Bulla Murray St.
The toffee caramel sauce is excellent.


Murray St. Banoffee is a delicious craft-style ice cream that should appeal to most. The banana ice cream is soft and creamy without too much sweetness. You’ll notice the taste of banana, but it doesn’t smack you in the face. 

The sauce adds a slight saltiness, perfect for balancing out sweetness. There’s only 8% sauce in the tub. I’d like to have seen more.

Fresh milk, cream, and free-range egg yolk give the ice cream an indulgent premium feel. The texture is soft and easily scoopable. It is rich, delicious, and tough to stop eating.

A partly eaten container of Banoffee Ice Cream.
There is 8% sauce in each tub.


The Murray Street Ice Cream range is made in Australia using local cream, milk, and egg yolks.

23% of this frozen dessert is milk and cream, providing a creamier, more premium product. Cheaper alternatives typically include more water, reconstituted skim milk, and other low-cost ingredients.

Toffee caramel sauce makes up 8% of the tub’s contents.

Ingredients list: Fresh milk, fresh cream (milk) (23%), sugar, water, milk solids, dextrose, sweetened condensed milk, glucose syrup, butter (milk), egg yolk, vegetable fat, emulsifiers (471, 422), burnt sugar, thickeners (guar gum, pectin, carrageenan), natural flavours, colour (caramel i), salt, acidity regulator (339).

Milk fat

Milk fat plays a vital role in ice cream’s texture and mouthfeel. More of it results in a creamier, smoother textured ice cream associated with superior ice cream.

Murray St Banoffee ice cream contains 12% milk fat. That’s higher than most family-pack ice creams like Blue Ribbon Streets or Peters but lower than brands like Haagen-Dazs.

Closeup photo of the Murray St Banoffee Ice Cream in a scoop.
Smooth and creamy ice cream with 12% milk fat.

Other popular reviews of this brand:

Nutrition information

No ice cream is good for you, so eat it in moderation. Murray St. Caramel Swirl has 8.7g of saturated fat per 100g and 23.8g of sugar.

Servings per package: 10
Serving size: 71g

Nutrition table

 Quantity per ServingQuantity per 100g
Fat, Total9.0g12.7g
Dietary Fibre


  • Excellent artisan ice cream in a decent-sized 1L pack.
  • Delicious balance of sweet banana and slightly salty caramel.
  • Made in Australia with fresh milk, cream, and egg yolks.


  • Not enough caramel sauce.

What other flavours are available in the Murray Street range?

Flavour options vary depending on the country, but you’ll find the following additional products in Australian stores:

  • Choc Mint Sundae.
  • Chocolate and Fudge Ripple.
  • Vanilla Bean.
  • Strawberries and Cream.
  • Vanilla and Boysenberry Swirl.
  • Honey and Salted Caramel Peanut.
A vertical front of pack shot of the Murray St Ice Creamery Banoffee flavour.
A tub sitting on the kitchen bench.

About the manufacturer

The Murray Street Ice Creamery has a range of premium ice creams sold in Australia and other parts of the world. The brand is owned by Bulla, an Australian company that has been making ice cream since 1929.

The factory where this ice cream is made is on the main street in Colac, Victoria.

Similar Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *